Review of 23 milk powder models of Meisujiaer: The most expensive one is really not recomm

Welcome to pay attention to baby reviews!

The long-awaited Meisujiaer milk powder review is finally here!

National Bank version, Hong Kong version, Dutch version, Singapore version, which version should I choose? Which one to choose? This time, Stupid Dad is here to give you a comprehensive review!

As usual, remind everyone: If you don’t want to see detailed data analysis, you can scroll directly to the end of the article to see the total score and summary; if you want to know more details and make a more targeted selection, then Please be patient and look carefully.

In addition, mothers who want to see reviews of Aptamil, Abbott, Wyeth, Mead Johnson, a2 and other brands of milk powder can check out Stupid Dad’s previous articles~

Statement: The milk powder review article published by Stupid Dad is from an independent and objective standpoint. It is not a soft article to be recharged, nor is it an article written for commercial purposes to sell milk powder.

1. Version & segment number

Version

Meisujiar is a Dutch brand. The best-selling versions in China mainly include: National Bank version, Hong Kong version, Dutch version and Singapore version. The first paragraph of each version is called "Frisolac", and the second paragraph and above are called "Friso".

①Meisu Jiaer Chinese version: divided into two series: gold and royal, both imported from the Netherlands in original cans.

Meisujiaer Gold uses "Dutch own ranch" and "no irritation, no constipation" as its selling points. The 1-4 segments have all been replaced with new packaging this year.

Royal Meisujiar claims to "contain natural and rare nutrients (natural lactoferrin, milk phospholipid, OPO, etc.)". Royal Meishujiaer has also changed its packaging and upgraded and adjusted its formula. However, in many stores, the 1-section Royal Meisu Li is still sold in the old version (the "Royal Meisu Jiaer Flagship Store" is also an old version).

Considering that there are certain differences in the formulas of the old and new versions, Stupid Dad has included the new version of 1-4 sections of Royal Meisu Jiaer and the old version of 1 section of Royal Meisuli in this review Review.

The National Bank version product picture is as follows:

②美Su Jiaer overseas version

Mei Su Jiaer Hong Kong version is also divided into two series: gold series and royal series. The Singapore version only has gold series, and the Dutch version is boxed. These overseas versions are also produced in original cans from the Netherlands.

The overseas version product picture is as follows:

Number of segments

In terms of segment division, Meisu Jiaer’s Chinese version, Singapore version and Hong Kong version Gold equipment is divided into levels 1-4, and the Hong Kong version and the Dutch version are divided into levels 1-3. In addition, the applicable age of the Dutch version is slightly different, as shown in the figure below.

2. Milk source & milk-based raw materials

Milk source

Meisu Jiaer Chinese version, Hong Kong version, Dutch version and Singapore version The milk sources of our products are all from the Netherlands, which is recognized as a high-quality milk source area.

The so-called high-quality milk source is not only the concept of a "golden milk source zone" (40-50 degrees north and south latitude), but also includes the breed of cows, pasture environment and management, and raw milk hygiene Quality control standards, etc.

Milk-based raw materials

In terms of raw materials, all versions of Meisujiaer use fresh milk, which is slightly better than milk powder in terms of freshness. As for whether whole milk or skimmed milk is used, there is no advantage or disadvantage in milk powder. The specific situation is as shown below.

In addition, only the Dutch version does not add flavors and fragrances throughout the entire section, while other versions add flavors and fragrances starting from section 3, which means they will have a heavier "milk flavor". These flavors and fragrances do not pose safety risks, but they may aggravate the baby's taste and easily cause a partial eclipse or difficulty in accepting light milk powder. Points will be deducted if the products are within the 3rd level, while the 4th level will have little impact and no points will be deducted. The specific situation is as shown below.

3. Comparison of basic nutrition

Basic nutrition is the basic ingredients necessary for the growth and development of infants and young children. National food safety standards require that infant formula milk powder should include several basic nutrients such as carbohydrates, fats, proteins, vitamins and minerals.

Stupid Dad used my country's "National Standard for Infant Formulas" as a criterion to compare the basic nutritional status of several Meisujiar milk powders.

Carbohydrates

Chinese national standards stipulate that the carbohydrate content of infant formula milk powder in the first segment should be within the range of 2.2-3.3g/100KJ, while other segments are not specified. Regulation. The carbohydrate content of each version of Meisujiaer milk powder is as follows.

In milk powder, lactose is the best source of carbohydrates for babies (unless the baby is lactose intolerant), especially milk powder in stages 1 and 2, followed by maltodextrin, starch, and corn syrup. solid or sucrose, etc.

The specific addition of glucose polymer in each version of Meisujiaer milk powder is as follows.

Summary:

①The carbohydrate content of all versions of Meisujiar's milk powder meets China's national standards.

②Except for the national version of Royal Meisujiaer, other versions start from paragraph 1 Maltodextrin is added. Most of the 3 and 4 segments contain glucose syrup and sucrose. These substances not only reduce the proportion of lactose in the milk powder, but also have little nutritional value except mainly providing calories. The sucrose may also cause tooth decay and weight gain in babies. It is a deduction item.

Fat

Chinese national standards stipulate that the fat content of stage 1 infant formula should be within the range of 1.05-1.4g/100KJ. 2. Section 3 should be within the range of 0.7-1.4g/100KJ. The fat content of each version of Meisujiaer milk powder is as shown below.

Summary:

①The fat content of all versions of Meisujiaer milk powder is in line with China's national standards.

②The National Bank version of the full series 1 section, the Hong Kong version of the full series of all sections, and the Dutch version of the full series Both sections and the Singapore version are added with α-linolenic acid, which is a fatty acid that helps improve baby’s intelligence and protect cardiovascular system.

③ The National Bank version and the Hong Kong version Royal series contain natural OPO structural lipids, which can provide rich fatty acids, optimize calcium absorption, and improve constipation. However, the content of the third segment is estimated to be limited.

It should be reminded that in the "no internal heat, no constipation" promoted by the Gold Edition of the Bank of China, "no internal heat" is a false concept, so don't take it seriously.

Protein

h3>

Chinese national standards stipulate that the protein content of infant formula milk powder in stage 1 should be within the range of 0.45-0.7g/100KJ, and that in stages 2 and 3 should be within the range of 0.7-1.2g/100KJ. The protein content of each version of Jiaer milk powder is as follows

Summary:

①The protein content of segments 2 and 3 of the Dutch version of Meisujiaer is lower than the national standard, and other versions are in line with the Chinese standard National standard.

② The national version of Royal Meisujiaer 1, 2, and 3 (excluding the old version 1), additional lactoferrin is added, and the amount added is relatively high among all milk powders High. This is a breast milk core immune protein that helps improve the baby's own immunity and promotes the baby's growth and development. It is a bonus. Judging from the ratio of whey protein and casein, it is also relatively conducive to absorption.

Vitamin

Compared with my country's national standards, the niacin content of Meisujiar Hong Kong Edition Gold Pack 3 is slightly insufficient, which is a kind of neurotoxicity for babies. , skin and blood circulation beneficial vitamins. The vitamin content of each other version is in line with national standards.

Minerals

Minerals that do not meet the national standards appear in the Singapore version of gold-packed 3-stage milk powder. The manganese content is too high. Long-term excessive consumption may be harmful to the baby's heart, kidneys, etc. Organ disadvantages. The specific situation is as shown below.

In addition, in the following models of Meisujiaer milk powder, there are several minerals whose contents are not marked. Since most of them are naturally present in milk-based ingredients, it is not clear whether they are really missing or simply not marked. In this regard, stupid dad will deduct points for them accordingly.

Summary:

①The vitamin and mineral content of the Chinese version and the Dutch version of Meisujiaer both comply with Chinese national standards .

②The Hong Kong version of Gold Level 3 has insufficient niacin content; the Singapore version of Gold Level 3 has excessive manganese content.

4. Comparison of fortified formulas

Fortified formulas are the "optional ingredients" in the ingredient list of milk powder. In addition to ensuring basic nutrition, most milk powders also Some additional strengthening ingredients will be added to help the baby's growth and development.

DHA/ARA

DHA (docosahexaenoic acid) and ARA (eicosatetraenoic acid) are Fatty acids that are very important for the baby's intelligence and vision development. my country's national standards stipulate that in infant formula milk powder, the amount of DHA added shall not exceed 0.5% of the total fatty acids, and the amount of ARA added shall not exceed 1% of the total fatty acids.

The DHA/ARA content of each version of Meisujiaer is as follows.

Summary:

①DHA content if ≧0.3%, ≦0.5% (total fat content), or 3.6mg/100kj The above is better for the baby's intelligence and visual development, and stupid dads will get extra points.

② From the perspective of DHA/ARA content, the Chinese version of Meisu Jiaer performs best (Royal is better than gold), followed by the Hong Kong version, the Dutch version and the Singapore version. The additions to each section of the version are relatively small.

③DHA and ARA are added to all versions of each version, but starting from paragraph 2, the content of ARA drops significantly.

5. Other fortified formulas

Other fortified formulas include: choline, inositol, taurine, L-carnitine, dietary fiber , nucleotides and lactoferrin, etc., the Meisujiaer milk powder containing fortified ingredients complies with the addition limits of my country’s national standards. The specific addition conditions are as follows.

Summary:

① In the milk powders 1 and 2, each version has a sufficient amount of fortified formula. Among them, the new national version of the royal series has added lactoferrin, which has more advantages.

②In the 3rd and 4th stages of milk powder, the Hong Kong version and the Dutch version added all types of other fortified formulas, but the amount added in the Dutch version of 3rd stage dropped significantly. The National Bank version and the Singapore version more or less lack several strengthening formulas.

③The National Bank version of gold version 1-3 and the Hong Kong version of gold version 1-4 have additional β-carotene, which is very good for improving eyesight and protecting eyesight. effect.

6. General review

Based on the above analysis, Stupid Dad integrated indicators such as milk origin, milk-based raw materials, basic nutrition and fortified formula. , carefully scored each version of Meisu Jiaer (out of 100 points). The specific scoring situation is as follows:

Based on the scoring situation, we can draw the following important summary:

1. Meisujiaer Stage 1 Milk Powder

①The basic nutrition of each version of Stage 1 milk powder all complies with Chinese national standards, strengthening the overall level of the formula All are relatively high.

②The National Bank version of Royal 1 has the highest ratings and total scores. Several other milk powders are deducted mainly because they contain maltodextrin, which is not recommended for babies aged 0-6 months.

Score: National Bank version of Royal> National Bank version of Gold, Hong Kong version of Gold> Hong Kong version of Royal> Dutch version, Singapore version of Gold

Recommendation: Recommend the new version of National Bank Royal 1.

2. Meisujiaer 2-stage milk powder

①Except Dutch version 2-stage milk powder In addition, the basic nutrition of other milk powders is in line with China’s national standards.

② In terms of strengthening and special formula, the National Bank version of Royal 2 is the best, the Hong Kong version of Royal 2 is second, and several other milk powders are slightly inferior and do not score high.

Score: National Bank version of Royal.> Hong Kong version of Royal> Hong Kong version, National Bank version of Gold> Singapore version of Gold> Dutch version

Recommendation: If you are not price-sensitive, buy the National Bank version of Royal 2. If you are price-sensitive, you can buy the Hong Kong version of Gold 2 through reliable purchasing channels.

3. Meisujiaer 3-stage milk powder

①Dutch version of protein, The niacin content of the Hong Kong version of Gold is slightly insufficient, but it’s not a big problem. The Singapore version of gold contains too much manganese, so it is not recommended to buy it. The basic nutrition of other milk powders meets the national standards.

②The scores of the enhanced formulas are not significantly different overall.

Recommendation: Since the total score of the Hong Kong version of Royal and the National Bank version of Royal are not much different, but the price of the Hong Kong version is much more expensive, so the National Bank version of Royal 3 is more recommended . The total score of the Dutch version of 3-stage is also relatively high, and the price is affordable, so buying the Dutch version of 3-stage is also a good choice for price-sensitive people.

4. Meisujiaer 4-stage milk powder

① Among the 4-stage milk powder, each The basic nutrition of this version all complies with Chinese national standards.

② Since the Hong Kong version and Singapore version of the gold equipment have slightly better special strengthening formulas, the score is slightly higher.

Recommendation: Recommend the Hong Kong version of Gold Level 4.

Price

In terms of price, Stupid Dad selected the official flagship stores of Meisu Jiaer on Tmall and JD.com and the official overseas flagship store in early October 2018. Price data from stores and other places are for your reference.

The most expensive one is Hong Kong Version KingHome, the second most expensive is the National Bank version of Royal. In this evaluation, the Hong Kong version lost to the National Bank version.

A few words here. People often say that the National Bank version is much more expensive than the overseas version. This is mainly because the price of the National Bank version also includes various transportation, taxes and fees. Costs include sales agency fees, store entry fees, shelf fees, publicity fees, etc., and it is not ruled out that foreign brands bully the Chinese people who are stupid and have too much money. In this regard, stupid dad could only sigh.

Okay, this issue of the Meisujiaer milk powder review is over. Do you have any questions? Do you also want to know which brands of milk powder are reviewed? Welcome to leave a message to Stupid Dad~ If you think the article is good, please forward it to support it!

More historical articles

1. Comprehensive evaluation of a2 milk powder: Overseas purchasing agents will not tell you these real differences!

2. Review of 31 Xibao milk powder models: Do you really need to go to the Netherlands to buy milk powder?

3. Comprehensive evaluation of Abbott's 46 milk powder models: so many versions, there are so many pitfalls!

4. Review of the latest and most complete version of Aptamil milk powder: How to choose 11 milk powders in 5 major versions?

5. Comprehensive evaluation of 38 Wyeth milk powders: Expensive ones may not be good!

6. Evaluation of 33 Mead Johnson milk powder models: What is the difference between a can of more than 400 and a can of more than 200?

Welcome to follow me. Stupid Dad will successively launch a series of brand milk powder reviews for everyone. From an independent and objective standpoint, we will provide you with some useful references for purchasing milk powder.

Trademark label：Review of 23 milk powder models of Meisujiaer: The most expensive one is really not recomm