Your current position is：evaluating

Review of 31 Xibao milk powder models: Do you really need to go to the Netherlands to buy

2024-07-27 14:30evaluating People have gathered around

Text/Stupid Dad

In the milk powder category, organic milk powder often appears as a high-end product. Many milk powder brands have specialized organic milk powder series, while some milk powder brands specialize in the concept of organic milk powder.

For example, the well-known German brand Xibao is a brand that specializes in organic baby food. Xibao milk powder is also an organic concept in the minds of many mothers.

In this issue, stupid dad is here to review Xibao milk powder. Take a look at the differences between its different versions. Some conclusions may not be what you think.

First of all, a statement: The milk powder review article published by Stupid Dad is from an independent and objective standpoint. It is not a top-up soft article, nor is it a commercial article written to sell milk powder. purpose article.

As usual, remind everyone: If you don’t want to see detailed data analysis, you can scroll directly to the end of the article to see the total score and summary; if you want to know more details, it is more convenient to select. Pertinence, then please be patient and look carefully.

1. Version number

Version

HIPP has many versions of infant formula milk powder. Including: National Bank version, German version, French version, Dutch version, British version, Hong Kong version.

① National Bank version: The old version was called "Combiotic". After the implementation of the new milk powder policy, it was renamed "Beixi" and the new packaging was replaced. The selling point is "naturally pure milk source, added prebiotics, balanced nutrition, etc." But please note that the National Bank version of Beixi is imported from France in original cans and has not yet obtained organic certification, so it is not organic milk powder.

②German version, French version:

Including "COMBIOTIK" ("COMBIOTIC") organic probiotics and "BIO" ordinary organic series. The German version of COMBIOTIK segments 4 and 5 have not yet obtained organic certification.

③The Dutch version, the British version, and the Hong Kong version: all have only one series of organic probiotics. Among them, the British version 4 and the Hong Kong version 3 and 4 have not obtained organic certification.

The product pictures of each version of Xibao are as follows:

Number of segments

In terms of segmentation, Xibao The Chinese version, the Dutch version and the French version are divided into paragraphs 1-3, the Hong Kong version and the British version are divided into paragraphs 1-4. The number of paragraphs in the two series of the German version is quite special. Parents should pay special attention to the details as shown below. /p>

2. Milk source milk base raw materials

Milk source

The national version of milk source comes from France, and other versions come from Germany, and they are all of high quality Milk source area.

Milk-based raw materials

In terms of raw materials, each version of Xibao performed better, all Fresh skimmed (raw) milk is used, which is slightly better than reconstituted milk in terms of freshness and solubility.

If the raw material is organic milk, stupid dad will give extra points. However, I would like to remind everyone thatthere are only two things that have been proven to be better than ordinary milk powder at present: organic milk contains more omega-3. - Fatty acids, phosphorus, and pesticide residue risks are lower. Other claims about how it is better in terms of nutrition and health are unreliable.

In addition, National Bank Edition 3. Vanilla bean extract is added to the German version of BIO 4, and bourbon vanilla extract is added to the German version of BIO 4. The effect is similar to that of essence. Both milk powders are suitable for babies over 1 year old, although there is no problem in safety. , but it is recommended that this age group should still eat lightly, so Stupid Dad will deduct points for these two milk powders

Other versions of Xibao do not have added flavors and fragrances.

3. Basic nutrition comparison

Carbohydrates

Summary:

①Xibao The carbohydrate content of all versions of milk powder complies with China's national standards.

② Except for the German version, the other versions do not contain glucose polymers and have higher lactose content.

③The German version of COMBIOTIK and BIO in segments 1-3 have added starch, which can increase the baby's satiety and make the baby more resistant to hunger. However, because the baby's digestive system is not yet mature, it may cause complications. Indigestion, and reducing the proportion of lactose in milk powder, are deducted points

Fat

< strong>Summary:

①The fat content of all versions of Xibao milk powder meets China's national standards

②The National Bank version. Section 1 and all other versions are added with alpha-linolenic acid, which is a fatty acid that helps improve baby’s intelligence and protect cardiovascular system.

③ All versions of Xibao use palm oil as the main source of fat. Palm oil is prone to saponification reactions with calcium, which affects the absorption of calcium and increases the chance of constipation.

Protein< /h3>

Summary:
① Among Xibao 2-stage milk powder, except for the National Bank version, the protein content of other versions is lower than the Chinese national standard .
② Among the Hibao 3-stage milk powder, the protein content of the German version, the British version and the Dutch version is lower than the Chinese national standard.
However. , in the new revised draft of the national standard for milk powder, the minimum value of protein content in paragraphs 2 and 3 has also been lowered, so there should not be a big problem in this regard..

Vitamin

Summary:

①German version COMBIOTIK 4-5 paragraphs and Hong Kong version 3 paragraphs, vitamins The content of A or D does not meet China’s national standards. Among them, vitamin D exceeds the national standard value, but it is not a big problem.

② In paragraphs 2 and 4 of the British version, the vitamin D, E or biotin content does not meet the national standard.

③The above versions of milk powder also have multivitamin deficiencies.

Minerals

< /p>

Summary:

① Hong Kong version, Dutch version, British version, French version COMBIOTIC 1 paragraph and Germany The PRE segment of COMBIOTIK has slightly insufficient selenium content.

②The German version of COMBIOTIK 4-5, the Hong Kong version 3 and the British version 4 have excessive potassium content.

③The German version of COMBIOTIK 4-5 paragraphs, the Hong Kong version 3-4 paragraphs and the British version 4 paragraphs, there are many minerals without marked content. Since most of them are naturally present in milk-based ingredients, it is not clear whether they are really missing or simply not marked. In this regard, stupid dad will also deduct points for them accordingly.

4. Comparison of enhanced formula

DHA/ARA

Summary:

①The DHA content is 0.3% (accounting for the total fat content), or more than 3.6mg/100kj, which is better for the baby's intelligence and visual development. Stupid dads will get extra points.

Only one segment of each version of Xibao has added DHA and ARA. In terms of content, there is not much difference between the versions. The French version of BIO 1 is slightly higher.

②The PRE segment and 1 segment of the German version of COMBIOTIC and BIO contain DHA and ARA in the ingredient list, but the specific content is not marked, so the data cannot be obtained. It will be given as appropriate in the overall evaluation. point.

5 other strengthening formulas

Summary:

① Additions to each version of Xibao milk powder The fortified formulas all comply with the addition limits of my country’s national standards.

② Each version of Xibao milk powder basically only adds a few fortified formulas in the first stage, and most of them are no longer added in the second stage and above.

③Except for the German version of BIO and the French version of BIO, other versions have added prebiotics and probiotics.

The focus on probiotics is also a selling point of Xibao milk powder. The role of probiotics is to promote the balance of intestinal flora and help babies digest and absorb better; prebiotics are the "food" of probiotics and are conducive to the reproduction of probiotics.

What is strange is that the French version of COMBIOTIC 3 does not add prebiotics and probiotics, so parents should pay attention.

6. General review

Based on the above analysis, Stupid Dad integrated indicators such as milk origin, milk-based raw materials, basic nutrition and fortified formula. , carefully scored each version of Xibao (out of 100 points). The specific scoring situation is as follows:

Based on the scores, we can draw the following important conclusions:

The overall score of each segment of the Dutch version of Xibao is relatively high, while the performance of the National Bank version of Xibao is average. This is slightly different from other foreign brands of milk powder that Stupid Dad has reviewed before. However, Stupid Dad still recommends that unless you have reliable overseas shopping channels, it is more secure to buy the National Bank version from official channels.

Let’s talk about it in sections.

1. Stage 1 milk powder

①Raw materials: The main difference in raw materials is whether they have obtained organic certification , whether to use organic fresh milk (scored 17 points) or ordinary fresh milk (scored 16.8 points).

②Energy: The difference in energy points comes from whether there is any failure to comply with the national standard (points deducted), whether glucose polymers are added (points deducted), and whether linolenic acid is added etc. (extra points), whether palm oil is used (deducted points), etc.

Linolenic acid is added to paragraph 1 of each version of Xibao, and palm oil is used. The German version of COMBIOTIK and BIO 1st segment also added starch, so they were deducted extra points.

③ Vitamins: Each version of Xibao has 1 segment, the vitamin content is in line with the national standard, and the scores are the same.

④Minerals: The version with 18 points has all the minerals in line with the national standard and is rich in copper and iodine; the version with 17.8 points has a selenium content slightly lower than the national standard and is deducted. points; the version that scored 16 points had mediocre performance and no bonus points.

⑤Fortified formula: Scoring is based on the types and amounts added to each version of the basic fortified formula of milk powder, as well as the addition of special fortified formulas (probiotics, prebiotics, etc.).

The version with 14.8 points has extra points for adding prebiotics and probiotics. The German and French BIO series have no extra points, but the French version of BIO is rich in choline. The score is slightly higher than the German version of BIO.

Recommendation: Recommend the Dutch version of COMBIOTIK 1 paragraph. Among the top-rated 1-section Xibao models, the Dutch version of COMBIOTIK 1-section has the lowest price and the best value for money.

2. Stage 2 milk powder

①Raw materials: Same as those in Stage 1.

②Energy: There are 2 sections in each version of Xibao, and points are deducted for adding palm oil. Except for the National Bank version, other versions have added linolenic acid, but the protein content is lower than the national standard. In addition, the German version of the 2nd stage also added points for starch, and the score was at the bottom.

③ Vitamins: British version of Combiotic 2, points will be deducted for insufficient biotin content. Other versions of vitamins all meet the national standards and have the same score.

④Minerals: Each version of Xibao has 2 levels. The mineral content is in line with the national standard and the scores are the same.

⑤Strengthening formula: consistent with the situation in paragraph 1. The Hong Kong version of COMBIOTIC Stage 2 is rich in choline and gets extra points.

Recommendation: Those who are not price-sensitive should buy the Hong Kong version of COMBIOTIK 2-segment, and those who are price-sensitive should buy the Dutch version of COMBIOTIK 2-segment.

3. Stage 3 milk powder

①Raw materials: Same as those in Stage 1. Paragraph 3 of the National Bank version was deducted extra points due to added spices.

②Energy: There are 3 sections in each version of Xibao, and points will be deducted for adding palm oil. Except for the National Bank version, all other versions have added linolenic acid, which gets extra points. The protein content of section 3 in Britain, France, Germany and the Netherlands was lower than the national standard and points were deducted. In addition, the German version of the 3rd section also added points for starch, and the score was at the bottom.

③ Vitamins: Hong Kong version of COMBIOTIC 3, points will be deducted if the content of vitamins A and D does not meet the national standards. Other versions of vitamins all meet national standards and have the same score.

④Minerals: Hong Kong version of COMBIOTIC Stage 3, the potassium content is higher than the national standard, and the contents of many minerals are not labeled, so points are deducted. Other versions of minerals comply with national standards and have the same score.

⑤Strengthening formula: consistent with the situation in paragraph 1.

Recommendation: Recommend the Dutch versionCOMBIOTIK 3 paragraphs.

4, 4 and 5 milk powder

Xibao 4 and 5 milk powder , there are many problems with vitamins and minerals. Although the German version of BIO 4 has the highest score, it does not contain any fortified formula and has added fragrances.

But to be honest, babies over 3 years old have a relatively diversified diet, and milk powder is no longer the main source of nutrition. Stupid dads don’t really recommend that babies over 3 years old continue to feed milk powder. Therefore, when it comes to selection, everyone depends on the ratings.

Price

In terms of price, Stupid Dad selected the official flagship store of Xibao Tmall and overseas flagship stores in late October 2018. Price data is for your reference.

Generally speaking, the price of Xibao milk powder is mid-to-low-end among foreign brands, which is related to its less fortified formula.

Okay, this issue of Xibao milk powder review is over. Do you have any questions? Do you also want to know which brands of milk powder are reviewed? Welcome to leave me a message~ If you think the article is good, please forward it to support it!